| 30 Sep 2013 | League | Cock n Balls v Black Horse | Alex Schlup | 2550 | 4690 | Jan Bithell |
| 7 Oct 2013 | League | Black Horse v Laughing Fish | Jan Bithell | 5280 | 1700 | Bill Kerr |
| 14 Oct 2013 | League | Plough v Black Horse | w/over | Jan Bithell | ||
| 21 Oct 2013 | League | Black Horse v Star | Jan Bithell | 3380 | 1440 | Tony Smith |
| 28 Oct 2013 | League | Glynde Club v Black Horse | Nigel Pead | 200 | 1750 | Jan Bithell |
| 11 Nov 2013 | League | Black Horse v Hassocks | Jan Bithell | 4040 | 2740 | Dilly Williamson |
| 18 Nov 2013 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Black Horse | Kevin Hall | 16980 | 1910 | Jan Bithell |
| 25 Nov 2013 | Knock-out Cup | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Jan Bithell | 1430 | 13140 | Kevin Hall |
| 2 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Jan Bithell | 4500 | 6800 | Jean Brackenridge |
| 9 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Glynde Club v Black Horse | Sandy Harmer | 5370 | 3250 | Jan Bithell |
| 16 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Black Horse v Star | Jan Bithell | 4030 | 3910 | Stewart Chant |
| 6 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse v Laughing Fish | Jan Bithell | 4500 | 6000 | Tony Jenner |
| 13 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Cock n Balls v Black Horse | Bob Procter | 1500 | 3860 | Jan Bithell |
| 20 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Hassocks v Black Horse | Jenny Edwards | 3370 | 3800 | Jan Bithell |
| 27 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse v Plough | Jan Bithell | 2690 | 3850 | Chase Newman |
| 10 Feb 2014 | League | Black Horse v Cock n Balls | Jan Bithell | 3610 | 930 | Adam Cheesmur |
| 17 Feb 2014 | League | Laughing Fish v Black Horse | Henry Brooks | 11690 | 2870 | Jan Bithell |
| 24 Feb 2014 | League | Black Horse v Plough | Jan Bithell | 3550 | 1890 | John Staplehurst |
| 10 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Black Horse | Alan Brackenridge | 10980 | 3690 | Jan Bithell |
| 17 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse v Glynde Club | Jan Bithell | 3070 | 1330 | Sandy Harmer |
| 24 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Star v Black Horse | Dave White | 2660 | 2470 | Jan Bithell |
| 31 Mar 2014 | League | Star v Black Horse | Stewart Chant | 730 | 7150 | Jan Bithell |
| 7 Apr 2014 | League | Black Horse v Glynde Club | Jan Bithell | 3570 | 2030 | Nigel Pead |
| 14 Apr 2014 | League | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Jan Bithell | 2060 | 4770 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 28 Apr 2014 | League | Hassocks v Black Horse | Andy Farmer-Wright | 3720 | 5420 | Jan Bithell |