| 3 Oct 2005 | League | Black Horse v Brewers Returns | Jan Bithell | 2970 | 590 | Peter Shaw |
| 10 Oct 2005 | League | CKRBL v Brewers Returns | Derek Taylor | 2060 | 1190 | Peter Shaw |
| 17 Oct 2005 | League | Brewers Returns v Brewers Droops | Peter Shaw | 1350 | 2860 | Andy Farmer-Wright |
| 24 Oct 2005 | League | Chailey Lodge v Brewers Returns | David Copping | 1590 | 1570 | Peter Shaw |
| 31 Oct 2005 | League | Brewers Returns v Firemans Arms | Peter Shaw | 410 | 1550 | Keith Newsam |
| 14 Nov 2005 | League | Laughing Fish v Brewers Returns | Andy Brooks | 2400 | 0 | Peter Shaw |
| 21 Nov 2005 | League | Brewers Returns v Bridge | Peter Shaw | 1010 | 5860 | Alan Brackenridge |
| 28 Nov 2005 | League | Brewers Returns v Pump House | Peter Shaw | 1310 | 1400 | Steve Jones |
| 5 Dec 2005 | League | Horns Lodge v Brewers Returns | James Hawkins | 2800 | 1220 | Peter Shaw |
| 12 Dec 2005 | League Cup | Bridge v Brewers Returns | Jean Over | 5470 | 0 | Peter Shaw |
| 16 Jan 2006 | League | Brewers Returns v Black Horse | Peter Shaw | 230 | 6170 | Dave Todd |
| 23 Jan 2006 | League | Brewers Returns v CKRBL | Peter Shaw | 1790 | 2170 | Dilly Williamson |
| 30 Jan 2006 | League | Brewers Droops v Brewers Returns | Richard Jeffrey | 1540 | 1230 | Peter Shaw |
| 6 Feb 2006 | Knock-out Cup | Firemans Arms v Brewers Returns | Keith Newsam | 2380 | 1500 | Peter Shaw |
| 13 Feb 2006 | League | Brewers Returns v Chailey Lodge | Peter Shaw | 740 | 2200 | Alan Hills |
| 20 Feb 2006 | League | Firemans Arms v Brewers Returns | Chris Watson | 1700 | 1690 | Peter Shaw |
| 27 Feb 2006 | League | Brewers Returns v Laughing Fish | Peter Shaw | 1550 | 1890 | Chris Ashford |
| 6 Mar 2006 | League Cup | Pump House v Brewers Returns | Shane McBrown | 790 | 690 | Peter Shaw |
| 13 Mar 2006 | League Cup | Brewers Returns v CKRBL | Peter Shaw | 710 | 2910 | Dilly Williamson |
| 20 Mar 2006 | League Cup | Black Horse v Brewers Returns | Jan Bithell | 0 | 1140 | Peter Shaw |
| 27 Mar 2006 | League Cup | Brewers Returns v Chailey Lodge | Peter Shaw | 530 | 1210 | Geoff Winson |
| 3 Apr 2006 | League | Bridge v Brewers Returns | Kevin Stoner | 2800 | 1430 | Peter Shaw |
| 10 Apr 2006 | League | Pump House v Brewers Returns | Jim McClenn | 2070 | 1090 | Peter Shaw |
| 24 Apr 2006 | League | Brewers Returns v Horns Lodge | Peter Shaw | 1280 | 2160 | Kevin Stevens |
| 8 May 2006 | League Cup | Brewers Returns v Laughing Fish | Peter Shaw | w/over |