| 30 Sep 2013 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Hassocks | Brian Muggeridge | 0 | 2600 | Andy Farmer-Wright |
| 14 Oct 2013 | League | Laughing Fish v Black Horse Rott. | Ian Lelliott | 10300 | 2990 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 21 Oct 2013 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Plough | Brian Muggeridge | 3000 | 2950 | John Staplehurst |
| 28 Oct 2013 | League | Star v Black Horse Rott. | Bob Osbourne | 5100 | 2930 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 11 Nov 2013 | League | Glynde Club v Black Horse Rott. | Mike Daw | 4180 | 2030 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 18 Nov 2013 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Black Horse | Brian Muggeridge | 2070 | 2470 | Richard Todd |
| 25 Nov 2013 | Knock-out Cup | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Dave Knight | 4220 | 4160 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 2 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Dave Knight | 2640 | 1950 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 9 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Star v Black Horse Rott. | Tony Smith | 5670 | 1780 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 16 Dec 2013 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Glynde Club | Brian Muggeridge | 370 | 7300 | Colin Southouse |
| 6 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Plough v Black Horse Rott. | Geoff Fairs | 6130 | 5540 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 13 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Laughing Fish v Black Horse Rott. | David Ingram | 11800 | 3070 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 20 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Cock n Balls | Brian Muggeridge | 4900 | 5820 | Mick Kirwan |
| 27 Jan 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Hassocks | Brian Muggeridge | 2980 | 8420 | Andy Farmer-Wright |
| 3 Feb 2014 | Knock-out Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Cock n Balls | Brian Muggeridge | 4010 | 470 | Huw Lincoln |
| 10 Feb 2014 | League | Hassocks v Black Horse Rott. | Dilly Williamson | 1820 | 5700 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 10 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Black Horse | Brian Muggeridge | 5870 | 3010 | Darren Newnham |
| 17 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Black Horse Rott. v Star | Brian Muggeridge | 3240 | 8680 | Dave White |
| 24 Mar 2014 | League Cup | Glynde Club v Black Horse Rott. | Chris Turner | 9390 | 3010 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 31 Mar 2014 | League | Plough v Black Horse Rott. | Fenella Fisher | 920 | 4210 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 7 Apr 2014 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Star | Brian Muggeridge | 100 | 3810 | Peter Payne |
| 14 Apr 2014 | League | Black Horse v Black Horse Rott. | Jan Bithell | 2060 | 4770 | Brian Muggeridge |
| 28 Apr 2014 | League | Black Horse Rott. v Glynde Club | Brian Muggeridge | 1160 | 4580 | Sandy Harmer |
| 12 May 2014 | Knock-out Cup | Laughing Fish v Black Horse Rott. | Bill Kerr | 2720 | 5730 | Brian Muggeridge |