| 3 Oct 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Plough | Phil Osborne | 1640 | 1410 | John Staplehurst |
| 10 Oct 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v County Oak B | Phil Osborne | 11620 | 930 | Zoe Stoner |
| 17 Oct 2016 | League | County Oak A v Blacksmiths Arms | Marcus Chipman | 1030 | 12320 | Phil Osborne |
| 24 Oct 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Hassocks Pub | Phil Osborne | 9360 | 2500 | Dilly Williamson |
| 31 Oct 2016 | League | Glynde Horse v Blacksmiths Arms | Roger Munn | 1870 | 4630 | Phil Osborne |
| 7 Nov 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Laughing Fish | Phil Osborne | 6150 | 1420 | Joseph Carpenter |
| 14 Nov 2016 | Knock-out Cup | Blacksmiths Arms v Glynde Horse | Phil Osborne | 3110 | 5080 | Ric Bithell |
| 21 Nov 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Cock n Balls | Phil Osborne | 8460 | 3080 | Darrell Skinner |
| 28 Nov 2016 | League | Plough v Blacksmiths Arms | John Staplehurst | 4600 | 5870 | Phil Osborne |
| 5 Dec 2016 | League | County Oak B v Blacksmiths Arms | Sandra Hall | 1350 | 4700 | Phil Osborne |
| 12 Dec 2016 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v County Oak A | Phil Osborne | 8330 | 3420 | Jack Baden |
| 19 Dec 2016 | League | Hassocks Pub v Blacksmiths Arms | Rob Hall | 4440 | 10770 | Phil Osborne |
| 9 Jan 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Glynde Horse | Phil Osborne | 1610 | 1690 | Jan Bithell |
| 16 Jan 2017 | League | Laughing Fish v Blacksmiths Arms | Andy Brooks | 210 | 8990 | Phil Osborne |
| 30 Jan 2017 | League | Cock n Balls v Blacksmiths Arms | Darrell Skinner | 1950 | 3300 | Phil Osborne |
| 6 Feb 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Plough | Phil Osborne | 11550 | 990 | Kevin Hutchinson |
| 13 Feb 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v County Oak B | Phil Osborne | 10920 | 1630 | Kevin Hall |
| 20 Feb 2017 | League | County Oak A v Blacksmiths Arms | Nigel Senior | 19280 | 180 | Phil Osborne |
| 27 Feb 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Hassocks Pub | Phil Osborne | 9510 | 1980 | Lorraine Hall |
| 6 Mar 2017 | League | Glynde Horse v Blacksmiths Arms | Jan Bithell | 3060 | 5560 | Phil Osborne |
| 13 Mar 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Laughing Fish | Phil Osborne | 10510 | 1460 | Ray Carpenter |
| 20 Mar 2017 | Knock-out Cup | Hassocks Pub v Blacksmiths Arms | Rob Hall | 2810 | 13560 | Phil Osborne |
| 27 Mar 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Cock n Balls | Phil Osborne | 5620 | 920 | Mick Kirwan |
| 3 Apr 2017 | League | Plough v Blacksmiths Arms | John Staplehurst | 1970 | 5650 | Phil Osborne |
| 10 Apr 2017 | League | County Oak B v Blacksmiths Arms | Alan Brackenridge | 600 | 10120 | Phil Osborne |
| 24 Apr 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v County Oak A | Phil Osborne | 5850 | 8650 | Nigel Senior |
| 8 May 2017 | League | Hassocks Pub v Blacksmiths Arms | Pete Edwards | 2430 | 7380 | Phil Osborne |
| 15 May 2017 | League | Blacksmiths Arms v Glynde Horse | Phil Osborne | 10410 | 1340 | Jan Bithell |
| 22 May 2017 | League | Laughing Fish v Blacksmiths Arms | Jim Ashford | 2230 | 3530 | Phil Osborne |
| 5 Jun 2017 | Knock-out Cup | County Oak A v Blacksmiths Arms | Jack Baden | 5100 | 9160 | Phil Osborne |